Does “We Were Liars” Have Romance?

In the captivating novel “We Were Liars” by E. Lockhart, the central question of whether the story contains romance is a topic of much debate among readers. Set on a picturesque island off the coast of Massachusetts, the novel revolves around the mysterious death of a young girl named Cadence. While the narrative primarily focuses on themes of family dynamics, betrayal, and secrets, many readers are left pondering whether there is an underlying romantic subplot.

The novel follows the story of Cady, a wealthy teenager who spends her summers on the island with her wealthy and dysfunctional family. Throughout the book, Cady grapples with the complexities of her family’s relationships, particularly with her cousins and her brother. While the story does not explicitly delve into romantic relationships, there are subtle hints that suggest a deeper connection between Cady and her cousin, Johnny.

One of the most significant moments that hints at romance is when Cady and Johnny share a tender moment on the beach. After a heated argument, they find solace in each other’s company, and Cady describes her feelings for Johnny as “a storm of confusion and affection.” This moment, though fleeting, is a powerful indication that there may be more to their relationship than just that of cousins.

Another indication of romance is the way Cady describes her feelings for Johnny throughout the novel. She often refers to him as her “best friend,” but the way she talks about him suggests a deeper emotional bond. For instance, when she reflects on their time together, she says, “We were liars, but we were also friends. And sometimes, that was enough.”

However, it is important to note that the novel does not explicitly confirm a romantic relationship between Cady and Johnny. The story is primarily focused on the mystery surrounding Cadence’s death and the impact it has on the family. The romantic elements are more of a side note, providing a glimpse into the complex emotions that drive the characters.

In conclusion, while “We Were Liars” does not have a central romantic subplot, there are subtle hints that suggest a deeper connection between Cady and Johnny. The novel’s focus on family dynamics and secrets leaves readers to interpret the nature of their relationship, making it a compelling and thought-provoking read. Whether or not you believe there is romance in the story, “We Were Liars” is a beautifully written novel that will keep you guessing until the very end.