Is Truly Devious a Romance?

In the world of mystery novels, Agatha Christie’s “The Murder of Roger Ackroyd” is often hailed as a groundbreaking work. However, in the realm of young adult fiction, “Is Truly Devious” by Maureen Johnson has carved its own niche, blending the intrigue of a whodunit with the allure of a romance. This novel, set in 1935, follows the adventures of a young girl named Alice and her quest to uncover the truth behind a mysterious murder on the elite Blackwood Orphanage Island. But is “Is Truly Devious” simply a thrilling mystery, or does it also delve into the depths of romance? Let’s explore this intriguing question.

The Romance in the Mystery

At its core, “Is Truly Devious” is a mystery novel, and the romance is secondary. However, Johnson masterfully weaves romance into the narrative, making it an integral part of the story. Alice’s growing affection for a fellow student, Miles, adds depth to her character and provides a sense of companionship in her quest for the truth. Their relationship is not the central focus, but it does play a significant role in Alice’s emotional journey.

The romance in “Is Truly Devious” is subtle and understated, which is a refreshing change from the often explicit romantic narratives found in young adult fiction. Johnson’s approach to romance is mature and thoughtful, allowing readers to explore the complexities of young love without the usual clichés and distractions.

The Impact of the Romance

The romance in “Is Truly Devious” serves several purposes. Firstly, it adds a layer of relatability to the story, allowing readers to connect with Alice on a more personal level. As she navigates the challenges of her investigation and her burgeoning romance, readers are able to experience the joy, heartbreak, and confusion that come with adolescence.

Secondly, the romance provides a counterbalance to the intense mystery. While the novel is filled with suspense and intrigue, the romance offers a moment of respite, allowing readers to catch their breath and reflect on the events that have unfolded. This balance between romance and mystery is what makes “Is Truly Devious” a compelling read.

Conclusion

In conclusion, “Is Truly Devious” is not a romance novel, but it does incorporate romance into its narrative in a meaningful way. The relationship between Alice and Miles adds depth to the story and enhances the reader’s emotional investment in the characters. While the mystery is the primary focus, the romance serves as a vital component that enriches the overall experience. So, is “Is Truly Devious” a romance? Perhaps it is, in its own unique and subtle way.